• Creative Test
  • About
  • Ordinary Creativity
  • Blog
  • Publications
  • Awkward?
  • Contact
  • Shop
  • Cart
  • Menu
  • Skip to left header navigation
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Heather Caliri: Awkward Christian

Awkward Christian

  • Creative Test
  • About
  • Ordinary Creativity
  • Blog
  • Publications
  • Awkward?
  • Contact
  • Shop
  • Cart

Integrity is the Opposite of Cutting Ourselves

Looking back, it’s still hard for me to pinpoint just where I went wrong in that conversation. I love the earnestness of the girl on that staircase, her eagerness to seek virtue, her willingness to have a hard conversation. I admire her desire to please God, to make wise choices, to follow the counsel of people she respected. But underneath it all, I imagined God as a kind of benevolent torturer.

November 6, 2018 //  by Heather

Can I tell you an embarrassing story?

Picture me and a guy I liked sitting together on some stairs on our college campus. We’re having a serious DTR. Since the first time I met this guy, I thought he was super-cute, and over the last year and a half, we’ve spent more and more time together. He’s genuinely nice, very serious about his faith, and craziest of all, he seems to like me too.

And in this conversation (this is the embarrassing part), I’m explaining very carefully why I cannot date him anymore. I’m not doing a very good job, either, because despite my sincere conviction that this DTR is necessary, I don’t really understand why I can’t date him, either.

As I go over my talking points again, his face ever more hurt and confused, my own stomach wrenched with dismay, I tell myself, this is what doing the right thing feels like. It’s hard.

I really wish I could go back and whap that girl upside the head.

Look—it doesn’t really matter that I didn’t date that guy; I like my husband, thank you very much. What chagrins me about that long-ago talk is not its effect on my dating life but the reasons I opened my mouth in the first place.

I did it because I thought that to have integrity, be pure, pursue virtue, I needed to cut my own heart out and serve it to God on a platter…

I was at The Mudroom earlier, talking about how purity culture led me away from finding God’s deep joy for my life. Join me there?  

Category: Awkward Emotions, Awkward Faith, Awkward HistoryTag: complementarian, complementarianism, crushing spirit, dating, dating life, denial, deny yourself, desire, DTR, egalitarian, Elisabeth Eliot, Elisabeth Eliott, Elizabeth Eliot, Elizabeth Elliot, Faith, fear, feminism, feminist, Freedom, headship, Imago Dei, Integrity Virtue Purity, Joy, Passion and Purity, purity culture, purity movement, relationships, scrupulosity, self-denial, self-loathing, serious faith, submission, submissive, Suffering, take up your cross

Recent Posts

all the parts of a machine (like a brain) laid out on a white background

Dear Awkward: How Can I Turn Off My Magnificent Brain?

Dear Awkward: Help! My family is a crazy mess at church.

Dear Awkward: Help! God said I would get married. I’m still single.

Quote: "Living with love is the most badass move in the book." on background of a silhouette of a woman doing a high karate kick, with green and yellow doodles around her

Dear Awkward: Help! My Co-Worker Scares Me!

atheltic sneaker in the air

Dear Awkward: My Pastor and Air Yeezys

Jesus doesn't need you Lent

Jesus Doesn’t Need You This Lent. Really.

goals stress

Goals Don’t Need to Stress You Out

goals that nurture your inner toddler from A Little Yes Live

A Little Yes Live: Goals that Nurture Your Inner Toddler

three lies that keep you busy

Three Lies that Keep You Busy in Your Faith

schedule

My Schedule is So Busy I Don’t Even Know How to Cut Something. Help!

zombies apocolypse

Houseplants Are Zombies of the Apocalypse: The Mudroom

frank peretti

This Is Not a Frank Peretti Novel

Previous Post: «zombies apocolypse Houseplants Are Zombies of the Apocalypse: The Mudroom
Next Post: My Schedule is So Busy I Don’t Even Know How to Cut Something. Help! schedule»

Copyright © 2025 Heather Caliri · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme